
The Arizona Supreme Court in Markham Contracting Co., Inc. v. Cahava Springs Phase I, Inc., et al. addressed whether improper conduct is required to maintain an unjust enrichment claim outside the landlord-tenant-contractor context.
In June 2026, the Arizona Supreme Court in Markham Contracting Co., Inc. v. Cahava Springs Phase I, Inc., et al. addressed whether improper conduct is required to maintain an unjust enrichment claim outside the landlord-tenant-contractor context. The Court held that the improper-conduct requirement does not extend beyond the landlord-tenant-contractor scenario. As a result, in the construction industry, this clarified that for certain projects, a contractor or subcontractor must meet only the “standard” elements to prove unjust enrichment, not the improper-conduct requirement.
In Markham Contracting Co., certain landowners, (the Landowners) and a District formed a development agreement to implement a financing structure to acquire and construct public infrastructure within Cahava Springs, a master-planned community. To fulfill its obligations to the Landowners, the District entered into a contract with Markham Contracting Co., Inc., to build out the public infrastructure. However, the Landowners were not a party to the contract. After significant improvements were made, a dispute arose between the District and Markham. The District halted payments to Markham and both parties filed claims. The claims went to arbitration, which resulted in a $6.5 million award for Markham. Markham then sued the Landowners for unjust enrichment, seeking to recover the $6.5 million award from the arbitration.
Reprinted courtesy of Creighton P. Dixon, Snell & Wilmer and Matthew Racioppo, Snell & Wilmer
Mr. Dixon may be contacted at cdixon@swlaw.com
Mr. Racioppo may be contacted at mracioppo@swlaw.com